Does the Practice of Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) Factors Impact Consumer Trust?

Does the Practice of Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) Factors Impact Consumer Trust?

In the current global economic landscape, the connection between sustainability efforts, consumer confidence, and economic growth is becoming increasingly apparent.

The rise of sustainability zeitgeist, coinciding with an increase in consumer future orientation across major economies, has sparked a significant shift in business practices. Embedding sustainability—environmental, social, and economic considerations—into business models and supply chain planning can reduce environmental harm while enhancing financial and operational performance, supporting economic growth [2][4].

Consumer confidence, it seems, is more sensitive to personal economic conditions but can be influenced by visible positive corporate sustainability practices that increase trust and brand appeal [1][3]. The visibility of sustainability initiatives can enhance brand value and consumer trust, which may bolster individual consumer confidence related to product choices and corporate reputation, thus potentially boosting spending.

Research indicates that sustainability efforts can improve consumers' perceptions of companies' long-term commitment to social and environmental responsibility, fostering more positive consumer sentiment and loyalty [2][3]. This, in turn, can contribute to economic growth by encouraging more confident consumer spending.

However, the practice of companies underreporting or obscuring their sustainability activity, known as greenhushing, can undermine brand equity and erode consumer confidence [5]. In a world where most economies are confidence machines, with consumers, businesses, and governments basing decisions on future expectations, the absence of transparent sustainability efforts can create a vacuum filled by doubt.

In fact, 64% of global respondents in Edelman's 2023 Brand Trust Report say that silence makes them suspicious [6]. Conversely, 73% of global respondents in the same report said they want to know what companies are doing behind the scenes on social and environmental issues [7].

The current backlash against ESG, DEI, and sustainability initiatives might have more significant consequences than just an economic sideshow. Dismantling social progress initiatives could potentially collapse the confidence on which modern economies depend.

The trust premium that sustainability generates comes from transparency, not virtue concealed in spreadsheets. The logic is that if the companies you trust won't speak confidently about the future, why should you spend confidently in the present.

In a 2021 OECD report, people who identify with sustainability concerns are more likely to make future-oriented financial decisions [8]. This suggests that sustainability, ESG, and DEI initiatives not only respond to confidence but help generate it.

In conclusion, the interplay between sustainability, consumer confidence, and economic growth is complex but positive, particularly when sustainability efforts are visible and effectively communicated to consumers. The visibility and communication of sustainability efforts enhance consumer sentiment by showing corporate responsibility, which can encourage more confident consumer spending and support economic growth.

1. The business case for sustainability is strengthened by the connection between sustainability efforts, consumer confidence, and economic growth.
2. Sustainable business practices, encompassing environmental, social, and economic considerations, can reduce environmental harm and enhance financial performance.
3. Consumer confidence can be influenced by visible positive corporate sustainability practices that increase trust and brand appeal.
4. Research indicates that sustainability efforts can improve consumers' perceptions of companies' long-term commitment to social and environmental responsibility.
5. Greenhushing, the practice of companies underreporting or obscuring their sustainability activity, can undermine brand equity and erode consumer confidence.
6. In the world where most economies are confidence machines, the absence of transparent sustainability efforts can create a vacuum filled by doubt.
7. Edelman's 2023 Brand Trust Report reveals that 64% of global respondents are suspicious when companies remain silent about their sustainability efforts.
8. On the other hand, 73% of global respondents in the same report express a desire to know what companies are doing behind the scenes on social and environmental issues.
9. The trust premium that sustainability generates comes from transparency, not virtue hidden in spreadsheets.
10. People who identify with sustainability concerns are more likely to make future-oriented financial decisions, suggesting that sustainability initiatives don't just respond to confidence but help generate it.

Read also: